War is the father of all things: Creative Destruction on Wikipedia and the arXiv

Simon DeDeo

Santa Fe Institute & Carnegie Mellon University, Bloomington (http://santafe.edu/~simon)

From the courtroom to the marketplace, the parliament building to the newsroom, some of our most important institutions are adversarial. We expect that placing individuals in conflict will help solve complex problems in information-dense environments, and will drive long-term social evolution through the creation of of new questions to answer. Yet we understand very little about the general principles that make conflict creative. This leaves a major gap in our understanding of human social development, and makes it difficult for us to mitigate the negative effects of conflict while retaining its benefits. To help remedy this, I present a new framework for the quantitative study of creativity and conflict. I apply it to a new study on the relationship between conflict and information creation in the online encyclopedia Wikipedia. Fifteen years of high-resolution records allow to track the long and tumultuous process by which Wikipedia articles are written, re-written, torn-apart and reconstructed. We can see not only how the introduction of new information into an article leads to conflict, but how conflict can often precede the creation of unexpected configurations whose long-term persistence suggests adaptive success. This work contradicts simple accounts that oppose conflict and cooperation, and suggests that popular conflict-suppression mechanisms may actually undermine Wikipedia’s success. It provides new evidence for the central role of conflict in creative evolution, and new methods to measure and quantify it across a wide variety of systems. Given time, I will present new, very recent, results comparing the statistics and timescales of innovation and creativity on Wikipedia to the papers posted on the hep-th, astro-ph, and gr-qc sections of the arXiv, Cornell University’s Physics Preprint Server, and discussion the prospects of finding new, generalizable principles for nurturing creativity in the scientific elite.

Location

London Mathematical Laboratory, 14 Buckingham Street, London, WC2N 6DF

Date & Time

Thursday 15th September 2016 at 14.00hrs

Information

LML Seminars are free to attend and no registration is required.